Time of clerkship rotations' interruption during COVID-19 and differences on Progress Test's scores

SUMMARY OBJECTIVES: The transition from face-to-face to remote teaching is yet to be fully understood. In clinical training, traditional teaching must prevail because it is essential for the acquisition of skills and professionalism. However, the responses of each school to the pandemic and the decision on when to resume clerkship rotations were mixed. In this study, we aimed to analyze whether the time to resume clerkship rotations was associated with the performance of the students by using a multi-institutional Progress Test. METHODS: This is a cross-sectional study conducted at nine different Brazilian medical schools that administer the same annual Progress Test for all students. We included information from 1,470 clerkship medical students and analyzed the time of clinical training interruption as the independent variable and the student's scores as the dependent variable. RESULTS: The comparisons of the students' scores between the schools showed that there are differences; however, they cannot be attributed to the time the clerkship rotations were paused. The correlation between the schools' average scores and the time to resume clerkship rotations was not significant for the fifth year (r= -0.298, p=0.436) and for the sixth year (r= -0.440, p=0.240). By using a cubic regression model, the time to resume clerkship rotations could explain 3.4% of the 5-year students' scores (p<0.001) and 0.9% of the 6-year students, without statistical difference (p=0.085). CONCLUSIONS: The differences between the students' scores cannot be attributed to the time when the schools paused the clerkship rotations.

Homeopathic potencies of Opium in alcohol dependence: exploratory open-label study / Potências homeopáticas de Opium na dependência do álcool: estudo exploratório e aberto / Potencias homeopáticas de Opium en alcoholismo: estudio exploratorio abierto

The conventional pharmacological options for the treatment of alcoholism are limited, which led to the search for solutions in alternative or complementary medicine (CAM). Homeopathy is a CAM modality recognized as medical specialty in Brazil. According to the clinical experience of the early homeopaths, Opium was used to treat patients with alcohol dependence. Aim: to perform a preliminary assessment of the effectiveness and tolerability of fifty-millesimal potencies of Opium in the treatment of alcohol-dependent patients. Methods: exploratory, prospective, open-label trial, with pre-treatment measures as control. Confidence intervals were used to estimate the magnitude of the clinical differences. Results: a total of 14 patients were included, from which 12 were evaluated (intention to treat analysis - ITT). There was a significant reduction in the average daily alcohol consumption (-29.37 units of alcohol/day; 95% CI=10.63; 48.11) and in the severity of alcohol dependence, measured by the mean score of the Short Alcohol Dependence Data questionnaire (-10.17; 95% CI= 4.12; 16.22). No serious adverse events were reported. Randomized controlled studies with larger samples are needed.

Contexto: as opções farmacológicas convencionais para o tratamento do alcoolismo ainda são limitadas, contribuindo para a busca de soluções na medicina alternativa ou complementar (CAM). A homeopatia é uma modalidade de CAM reconhecida como especialidade médica no Brasil. Na experiência clínica dos primeiros homeopatas, Opium era usado no tratamento de pacientes com dependência do álcool. Objetivo: avaliação preliminar da efetividade e da tolerabilidade de dinamizações homeopáticas de Opium no tratamento de pacientes dependentes do álcool. Métodos: estudo exploratório, prospectivo e aberto, com medidas pré-tratamento como controle. Intervalos de confiança foram utillizados para se estimar a magnitude das diferenças clínicas. Resultados: 14 pacientes foram incluídos e 12 avaliados (análise segundo a intenção de tratar- ITT). Houve uma redução clinicamente significativa no consumo médio diário de álcool (-29,37 unidades de álcool/dia, 95% CI=10,63; 48,11) e na severidade da dependência do álcool, medida pelo escore médio do questionário Short Alcohol Dependence Data (-10,17 pontos 95% CI= 4,12; 16,22). Não foram relatados ou observados eventos adversos graves. Os resultados justificam estudos maiores, randomizados e controlados.

From pharmaceutical standardizing to clinical research: 20 years of experience with fifty-millesimal potencies

Background: 20 years ago we began to standardize the procedures of preparation and use of fifty-millesimal dilutions (LM or Q) according to indications in the 6th edition of Hahnemann?s Organon. Aim: to describe the main stages in standardization as well as our teaching and research experience on Organon 6th edition. Results: with the use of standardized LM dilutions we observed a lower incidence of homeopathic aggravation than with our earlier experience with non standardized preparations. Organon.modus, a clinical-pharmaceutical protocol derived from the standardization was adequate for the teaching of homeopathy at Faculty of Medicine of Jundiai (São Paulo), the first Brazilian medical school with a graduate course on homeopathy. A randomized double-blind trial comparing individualized homeopathic medicines prescribed in LM dilutions and fluoxetine showed the former not be inferior to the latter in the treatment of moderate-to-severe depression. Conclusion: protocol Organon.modus showed to be adequate to graduate-level teaching of homeopathy and efficient in a controlled clinical trials, favoring its use as common denominator between the art of healing and medical science.

Tratamento homeopático da depressão: relato de série de casos / Homeopathic treatment of depression: series of case report

CONTEXTO: Não há estudos metodologicamente adequados sobre a eficácia da homeopatia na depressão. Relatos de casos clínicos são os primeiros degraus da evidência clínica, a caminho de estudos controlados. OBJETIOS: Relatar resultados preliminares do tratamento homeopático de pacientes com depressão no SUS de Jundiaí. MÉTODOS: Revisão dos prontuários dos casos novos, atendidos entre março e dezembro de 2006. O diagnóstico foi confirmado por entrevista estruturada. Os pacientes receberam homeopatia individualizada e a evolução foi avaliada pela escala de Montgomery & Åsberg (MADRS). RESULTADOS: Foram tratados 15 casos e observou-se resposta terapêutica (redução maior que 50 por cento dos escores de depressão) em 14 pacientes (93 por cento), após uma média de sete semanas de tratamento; um paciente apresentou piora clínica e foi encaminhado ao tratamento convencional. O escore média (± dp) na Escala de Avaliação de Depressão de Montgomery-Åsberg diminuiu de 24,9 (± 5,8) a 9,7 (± 8,2, p < ,0001) na segunda avaliação, resultados mantidos no decorrer da terceira e quarta consultas. CONCLUSÕES: Os resultados sugerem que a homeopatia pode ser uma alternativa terapêutica no tratamento da depressão, mas estudos randomizados e controlados são necessários para se testar a eficácia e segurança do tratamento homeopático dos transtornos depressivos.

BACKGROUND: Evidence for the efficacy of homeopathy for depression is limited due to lack of clinical trials of high quality. Case reports are the first steps of clinical evidence, towards controlled trials. OBJECTIVES: To report preliminary results of homeopathic treatment of depression in Jundiai's public health system, Sao Paulo. METHODS: Review of the medical records of new patients, treated between March and December 2006. Their diagnosis was confirmed by a semi-structured interview. Patients received individualized homeopathy and their response was measured by the Montgomery & Åsberg depression scale (MADRS). RESULTS: Fifteen patients were treated and response (more than 50 percent decrease of MADRS scores) was observed in 14 patients (93 percent), after an average of seven weeks of treatment; one patient had clinical worsening and was refered to conventional antidepressant therapy. The MADRS mean scores (± dp) decreased from 24.9 (± 5.8) to 9.7 (± 8.2, p < .0001) in the 2nd evaluation, and these results signifcance were sustained through the 3rd and 4th assessments. DISCUSSION: these results suggest that homeopathy may be an alternative therapeutics for depression, but randomized and controlled studies are needed to test the efficacy and safety of the homeopathic treatment of the depressive disorders.

Indicacoes e contra-indicacoes dos medicamentos paliativos e antimicrobianos: segundo uma analise da doutrina e da pratica de Hahnemann / Palliatives and antibiotics, when to prescribe, when to proscribe: according to an analysis of Hahnemann's doctrine and practice

Os autores analisaram a obra de Hahnemann procurando principios e exemplos que pudessem auxiliar o homeopata a entender quando e por que indicar ou contra-indicar paliativos e antimicrobianos modernos, bem como o papel dos microorganismos no modelo hahnemanniano de doenca.

Vacina: agressao isopatica ou cura homeopatica por antecipacao? / Vaccine: isopathic agression or homeopathic cure in advance?

O preconceito de que a homeopatia e contraria a vacinaca moderna levou os autores a uma analise do problema, objetivando a formulacao de que um conceito doutrinario a partir dos principios estabelecidos por Hahnemann. Concluiram que a vacinacao e uma especie de cura homeopatica por antecipacao, explicada pela extrema semelhanca entre a vacina e seu respectivo agente infeccioso natural

Tecnicas de dinamizacao / The dynamization techinics

Os autores compararam as normas tecnicas para a dinamizacao nos metodos centesimal e cinquenta-milesimal, descritas na literatura de 8 paises, com os procedimentos estabeecidos por Hahnemann. Divergencias foram evidenciadas, e suas provaveis consequencias clinicas analisadas, segundo os principios hahnemannianos. Os autores concluem ressaltando a necessidade de uma padronizacao que permita a comparacao cientifica de experiencias clinicas realizadas com os mesmos metodos, em diferentes regioes. Sugerem o metodo de Hahnemann como padrao, para que esse possa ser testado e desenvolvido cientificamente.

Tecnicas de dinamizacao: divergencias e necessidade de padronizacao / Technical norms of dynamization: divergencies and needs of padronization

Os autores compararam as normas tecnicas para a dinamizacao nos metodos centesimal e cinquenta-milesimal, descritas na literatura de 8 paises, com os procedimentos estabelecidos por Hahnemann. Divergencias foram evidenciadas, e suas provaveis consequencias clinicas analisadas, segundo os principios hahnemannianos. Os autores concluem ressaltando a necessidade de uma padronizacao que permita a comparacao cientifica de experiencias clinicas realizadas com os mesmos metodos, em diferentes regioes. Sugerem o metodo de Hahnemann descrito na VI ed. do organon como padrao, para que esse possa ser testado e desenvolvido cientificamente